Skip to content

Hung juries and retrials

5 cases

Cases where a jury could not agree or a judge stopped the trial before a verdict, so the case was tried again. The retrials ended differently: convictions, a manslaughter plea, and one acquittal — where a civil suit continues.

Who’s included: A jury couldn't agree or a judge stopped the trial before a verdict.

John O'Keefe

A Boston police officer found unresponsive outside a home in Canton, Massachusetts, in January 2022. The first trial ended in a mistrial when the jury could not agree; at the 2025 retrial his girlfriend was acquitted of second-degree murder and manslaughter and convicted of driving under the influence.

  • Fuk-Fu Joseph Kwok and Mei Han Chong

    A couple killed in their Auckland home in 2023. The first trial was stopped in 2025; by 2026 one man had pleaded guilty to manslaughter and the other had been convicted at retrial.

  • Hae Min Lee

    Killed in Baltimore in 1999. The first trial ended in a mistrial, and a second jury convicted her ex-boyfriend in 2000; that conviction was later set aside and reinstated.

  • Travis Alexander

    Killed at his home in Mesa, Arizona, in 2008; a jury convicted his ex-girlfriend in 2013. Two penalty juries then could not agree on a sentence, and she was sentenced to life in prison in 2015.

  • Cara Evelyn Knott

    A San Diego State University student killed while driving home in 1986. The first jury split 7–5 in 1988; a second jury convicted the highway patrol officer who had pulled her over.

Newspaper clippings from the record: John O'Keefe, Cara Knott, Hae Min Lee, Travis Alexander

Every fact on this page comes from the linked case page, which links to its court documents and sources. Open a case to read its full record or follow it for updates.

Browse all collections